Alloy.com
Photo: Splash News

Amber Tamblyn

In the case of the bad dress, we find Amber Tamblyn guilty. But, dear jurors, would you sentence her to red carpet probation for this style misstep? Do you think this is just a pretty dress and a bad fit? Or do you think the whole darned thing should be unlawful? Vote now below and shout out in the comments!

You Say!