16 American Horror Story Fan Theories So Crazy They Could Be True

By  | 

2. The series as a whole exists in two different universes.


Sure, it’s been basically proven that all the seasons exist in the same timeline, but what if it’s actually two different universes? Hardcore fans have noticed that although there are plenty of minor crossovers throughout all the seasons, major crossovers seem to stick to the same pairs or groups of seasons. For example, we know Murder House exists in the same universe as Hotel (due to The Countess’s failed abortion) and Roanoke (due to Piggy Man), but does it exist in the same universe as, say, Asylum? And we know Freakshow, Asylum, and Cult have minor degrees of separation, but what about the rest? This is a theory that may not be solved for certain until American Horror Story is finished for good.