Last year, we doled out awards to our fave celebs in categories like "Best Smile," "Best Dressed," and more. But then we wondered, what senior superlatives did the stars really get in high school -- were they class clowns or teachers' pets? And more importantly, what honors would they bestow upon themselves today? So we went directly to the source! See what superlatives Jesse McCartney, Pete Wentz, and eight other stars nabbed... and which they wish they'd gotten.

NEXT SLIDE