Sometimes, losing on a reality show can be the best thing that's ever happened to you. Exhibit A: Jennifer Hudson was eliminated on American Idol, struck out on her own solo singing career, and won an Oscar. Exhibit B: David "Punk" Ortunga wasn't chosen by New York on I Love New York 2 and found love with Jennifer. Now, the two reality show losers are engaged! David popped the question on Jennifer's 27th birthday, after the couple had been together for under a year, her rep tells Us Weekly. "I am very happy," Jennifer recently told the mag. "I don't think I have ever been happier." Congrats!