David Cook!

While Paula, Simon, and Randy all dubbed David Archuleta the winner on Tuesday night, 12 million more voters called in for the elder David. (The judges even backtracked on last night's show. "I want to congratulate both of you. I went back home to watch it, and it wasn't quite so clear-cut as we called it," Simon conceded.)

P.S. -- We'll have interviews with both Davids soon, so keep you eyes peeled for 'em!