Here's Jesse's rundown of the night:

I went to MSG so Justin Timberlake could propose to me in front of everyone. Unfortunately that didn't happen, but he put on an AMAZING show -- over two hours!

Anyway, back to J.T. HOTT! He was super close with one blonde dancer in particular throughout the show (I was so jealous!). Besides dancing and singing, J.T. played guitar, piano, and keyboard, and he looked so good sweating throughout it all. For me, the night's highlights were "What Goes Around Comes Around," "My Love," "Damn Girl," and "Cry Me a River." Timberland also made an appearance, performing a 20-minute DJ set with custom animation and live video behind him. BTW, Timberland deserves big props 'cause he’s the talent behind a lot of Justin's hits.

Oh -- and he also did one verse of "Gone." I left after what I thought was the last song only to find out that he and my OTHER boyfriend, Andy Samberg performed their song from SNL, "**** in a Box." Needless to say, I was already upset leaving without J.T., but now to find out there was more?!?! I think I’m going to the show on Long Island next month to catch it again -- no joke.

Jeneice had nothing but love for J.T., too:
Granted, I may be biased by my fondness of Justin, but I dare say last night was one of the most fabulous and fantastic shows I have seen in forever. Pink opened and set the stage for J.T., who started with "FutureSex/ LoveSound." Hot dancing, singing, and soulful piano playing -- could I ask for anything more?!?

Big surprise of the night: Who also loves J.T.? The Donald! He wooed the crowd of anxious ladies with a grand entrance to his prime seating just before J.T. took over the stage. So weird! Rumor has it that single lady (and J.T.-ex), Britney made a special guest appearance to catch the sold out MSG show -- wonder what she thought about "Cry Me A River"…