OK -- we're officially confused. Mandy Moore's been flying under the radar for some time now, and now we have not one, but two possible suitors for our Candy girl. At first, we thought she was hooking up with old flame, Wilmer Valderrama. But recent photos taken in L.A. suggest that our fave Candy girl is getting cozy with Nicole Richie castoff, DJ AM.

In any case, we guess the dating fairy granted AM his wish to snag a famous girl to hang with. Hopefully, Mandy's up on her Alloy Gossip, in which case she'd already know that…