Carrie Underwood

"For my birthday a boyfriend of over a year got me flip flops, a Freddie Vs. Jason DVD, like a box of candles, and like a potpourri burner. I was just like, 'You just went to the store, you just came from the store and you just bought a bunch of stuff and brought it over for my birthday.' It was my 21st birthday, too. He made it up to me by cheating on me."

NEXT SLIDE