The Nice Guy

You'd fall for him because...
Well, just look at this guy! How could you not want to be his girlfriend. He screams nice. Before the pair busted, Scarlett told Allure: "Josh is very sweet. He's a good boy. A great person. I'm very lucky and I'm very happy."

He'd break your heart when...
The nice guy front wears off, and it turns out he's a total dog. Josh hopped from hooking up with Black Dahlia co-star Scarlett Jo to hooking up with his 30 Days of Night co-star Amber Sainsbury.

NEXT SLIDE