Tony Romo

Carrie tried to keep her relationship with Tony Romo under wraps and downplayed the relationship ever since the beginning. Carrie told Women's Health that they were actually never boyfriend/girlfriend. "We're really good friends, we hang out a lot, and we're close...well, friends smooch occasionally," she said. Guess she must have left some impression on the football player 'cause Tony kept her number on speed dial. Carrie told Allure that he'd call her up while he was dating Jessica Simpson and she'd ignore his calls. Eek!

NEXT SLIDE