Jennifer Love Hewitt

John dated Jennifer in 2002 for a short but intense romance. "It was a strange little detour that I took for a minute," he tells Entertainment Weekly. But don't get him wrong, he said he was "madly in love" with the Ghost Whisperer star. "It sucks. Because the idea of it was fantastic. It just didn't work," he said. What went wrong? 'Cause rumor had it that Jennifer was the muse behind "Your Body is a Wonderland." Jennifer denied the rumor and says to People "John would have written, 'Your body is a disaster.'" We think she's just being modest!

NEXT SLIDE