Lauren Conrad

Next on his list: Lauren. They couple first dated in 2006, but when things went sour, they headed back to friend zone. But the romance wasn't completely dead, the lovebirds rekindled their flame last season on The Hills. Remember? Brody went to Vegas celebrate his birthday, and Lauren planned a surprise visit and later planted a kiss on the birthday boy. He's not the only one who was thrilled about the smooch. "When I kissed him on his birthday, his mom was there, and walked over and gave him the double thumbs," Lauren tells People. "I almost died!" But things went downhill after Lauren left for Paris. She got a phone call from Audrina who broke the shocking news: Brody has a new girlfriend. Drama, drama, drama!

NEXT SLIDE